“May you be happy with the life you have chosen.”
Audiences have long embraced Charles Dickens’ 1843 classic A Christmas Carol. There seems to be a new adaptation every six minutes. And though this film appeared to be an ironic vehicle for Johnny Depp’s inevitable redemption tour, I expected little from the holiday-timed cash grab.
I don’t stand fully corrected. But I do stand.
Set in Victorian London in 1836, Depp stars as Ebenezer Scrooge, a miserable businessman who, after losing his business partner on Christmas Eve, descends into a dark and lonely existence. The film then jumps ahead seven years, giving Scrooge time to sink deeper into depression as he grapples with his sudden isolation. The passage of time adds depth and complexity to a character whose loneliness has become all-consuming.
It was only a matter of time before Depp got his hands on Scrooge. A master of design, the combative actor has a knack for crafting memorable characters. His partnership with West feels like another inevitable pairing, bringing a bona fide world to life as Scrooge encounters three ghosts and embarks on a heavy dose of introspection.
Ian McKellen, Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley, and Tramell Tillman all deliver in supporting roles. But it’s difficult to see Ebenezer as anything but a Depp vehicle. And Depp delivers, bringing a degree of empathy to a character often reduced to cynical, villainous behavior.
As we voyage through the three Christmas ghosts and become further entrenched in Scrooge’s world, we welcome West’s dark take. Embracing the story's horror elements, Ebenezer is not a family affair. West’s gothic-centric approach is refreshing, sensationally blending the darker themes of the large-scale narrative with the lighter, more positive angle of the story’s ultimate conclusion. An unapologetic period piece, the film immerses its audience in the time period while crafting a tale that remains universal across time and place.
Credit Depp’s makeup department. While the film leans into the darker themes of the original novella, its visual odyssey is what gives the story its grit. Tramell Tillman’s turn as the Ghost of Christmas Present paints a haunting picture that fully grips your attention. Even during an otherwise mundane second act, the film draws strength from its source material, giving audiences a morally concrete story to reflect on and act on when they need it most.
But while the bar was extremely low, Ebenezer isn’t a full-blown success. Rather, the film struggles to find its identity. Though West’s dark sensibilities are a home run in capturing the story’s deeper identity, the overall film shifts sharply between tones. Structured in chapters, it struggles to find its flow as it attempts to tell a transitional story from a unique angle.
In many ways, the format works. And West deserves credit for understanding the balance. But there are moments when the stars refuse to align, leaving Ebenezer stranded on a deserted island, unable to find its direction as it struggles to chart a straight path toward its ultimate destination.
Still, West infuses his horror roots into the Christmas tale to near perfection, producing an unexpectedly feverish result that lends a chilling undertone to an otherwise light and airy narrative. In this era of remakes and reboots, bringing a fresh sense of uniqueness to an aging IP is difficult. Ebenezer isn’t great. But it’s far from poor. And given the holiday theme, you have to give credit where it’s due. West and Depp have more than earned it.